Skip to main content

Music: From Monoculture to Silots

 

I recently watched a video titled "What’s a Monoculture? How Artists Are Bigger and Smaller Than Ever" on YouTube, which got me thinking about the shift from music monoculture to silos. This change has significantly impacted how we consume and experience music today.

Monoculture and Silos:
- Monoculture: This refers to a shared cultural experience where a few artists or pieces of content dominate the global scene. This was more prevalent during the MTV era when music videos and a few popular artists shaped the music landscape.
- Silos: In contrast, silos represent the fragmented nature of modern media consumption. Different groups of people are exposed to different content based on their preferences, leading to a more personalized but less universally shared experience.

from DALL·E 3
 

How Did This Happen?

Here is a timeline of the last 70 years of modern music to illustrate this shift:

Pre-MTV Era (1950s-1980s):
- Music was primarily consumed through radio, records, and live performances.
- Music videos were rare and mainly used as promotional tools.

MTV Era (1981-2000):
- 1981: Launch of MTV, revolutionizing the music industry by providing a visual platform for artists and fostering a shared cultural experience (monoculture).
- MTV turned music videos into an art form and a marketing tool, significantly influencing pop culture and the music industry.

File Sharing Era (1999-2001):
- 1999: Launch of Napster, a peer-to-peer (P2P) file sharing application that allowed users to share music files directly, leading to widespread piracy and legal challenges.
- 2001: Napster ceased operations after losing multiple lawsuits.

Online Retailers (2003-2010):
- 2003: Launch of iTunes, creating the first legitimate digital music store that effectively challenged piracy and allowed consumers to purchase individual songs.
- iTunes became the world's largest music retailer and significantly impacted how music was bought and sold.

Internet and Social Media (2000s-Present):
- The rise of the internet and social media platforms further fragmented the music audience, allowing for a more diverse range of artists to reach niche audiences.
- Social media democratized music discovery and promotion, enabling artists to connect directly with fans.

Ad-Supported Streaming Services (2008-Present):
- 2008: Launch of Spotify, introducing a freemium model with both ad-supported and premium subscription options.
- Spotify transformed music consumption by offering instant access to a vast library of songs and using advanced algorithms for personalized playlists.

Algorithms and Personalization (2010s-Present):
- The use of algorithms by streaming services and social media platforms personalized music consumption, making it easier for listeners to discover new music tailored to their tastes.
- Algorithms contributed to the fragmentation of the audience and the decline of monoculture.

There is no better situation before or now, but for those who don't take the time to find silos that suit them, they could be lost today.

[Text reviewed by AI]

Sources:
The Evolution of Pop Music Industry: From the 1950s to 1970s
State of the Music Industry 2024: Trends and Challenges | iMusician
Do You *Actually* Miss The Monoculture? : r/LetsTalkMusic - Reddit
Can monoculture survive the algorithm? - Vox
Monoculture Definition & Meaning - Merriam-Webster
Evolution of Music from the 1950's to the 2000's
9 music trends to see in 2024 | Native Instruments Blog
Silo Definition & Meaning - Merriam-Webster
What's a Monoculture? How Artists Are Bigger and Smaller Than Ever



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Learning about Data Science?

This is the end of a beautiful summer, and also one of the warmer recorded in France. I’m continuing my journey in the product management world and today I’m living in the product marketing one too. I will blog about this later. During this first half of this year, I read several articles on big data and started to understand how important the data science discipline is. Being able to define a direction/goal to search, collecting the proper data, then using a collection of techniques to extract something others can’t see - it sounds like magic. Also, when I listened to the Udacity Linear Disgression podcast episode “Hunting the Higgs”, I understood people with these skills can be better at solving a problem than the domain experts themselves. Katie Malone explained that in a competition to solve a particle physics problem, the best results came from machine learning people. Then I read the article about Zenefit on the vision mobile website : “Zenefits is an insurance compan...
5 comments
Read more

What I’m learning about AI agents

My learning journey in the world of AI, updated for 2026 Originally published in March 2025. Updated in August 2026. I started this list because I kept seeing the same terms used in different ways. I needed a simple map to understand what each technology actually does, and where it may be useful when bringing AI into a product. AI changes so quickly that a learning journey can become dated in a few months. My first version of this article was an attempt to map the technologies around AI agents and to make sense of the growing number of tools. Since then, the topic has moved from interesting experiments to real business systems. This updated version keeps the original intention: learn in public, organise the landscape, and focus on what is useful in practice. What changed since 2025 In early 2025, most conversations were still about chatbots, prompt engineering and early agent frameworks. In 2026, the more useful question is no longer "which model is the best?" but ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Embracing Bluesky: A search for authentic dialogue beyond professional networks

LinkedIn is great for professional networking, but where can you have conversations with different people on a wider range of topics? I joined Twitter in 2008, later than many of my peers. Initially, it served as a platform for personal intellectual growth, offering pleasant exchanges focused primarily on computer science, human organisation, design and product management. But the growing awareness of climate issues changed everything. Anger became the dominant tone, and I found myself missing a more constructive environment. I don't want to spend my days in a world full of anger. In search of a new wave of self-improvement and more balanced discussions, I've made the move to: https://bsky.app/profile/lookingforanswers.me  I look forward to connecting with you there for more diverse and enriching conversations.
Post a Comment
Read more